Why Metal Roof Coatings Fail (And How to Avoid it)

Feb 9, 2026
By
Jamie Unruh

Metal roof coatings are a great product that have been shown to increase the life of a metal roof by decades. Coatings can hold up to our topsy turvy weather and protect from all kinds of elemental surprises such as wind, hail and extreme heat.

Adding a protective coating reinforces a metal roof’s durability, but if the coating fails, then you’re pretty much right back where you started. So, what can you do to prevent this? What leads a coating to breakdown?

There are three things that can cause a metal roof coating to fail: mistakes in preparation of the roof, errors in applying the coating, and problematic environmental conditions.

"There are three things that can cause a metal roof coating to fail"

Improper Prep

Preparation is key for any type of installation to come out perfect. Double checking that the groundwork is complete is especially important when spraying a roof coating.

An installer not doing his or her due diligence in correctly preparing the surface of a metal roof is likely going to see the eventual failure of the coating they’re installing.

Adhesion is the name of the game, and the coating won’t stick if the roof is dirty or wet.

Older roofs exposed to the elements are especially in need of careful preparation. Not only does the surface need to be clean, but it needs to be dry too. If there’s any dew, frost or other moisture, the coating won’t adhere to the metal.

Not clearing the roof of any flaking material that was previously installed will have the same result.

Making sure the screws and metal membrane layers are pretreated properly with mastic grade coating or caulking is also necessary to ensure a good coating will stick for years to come.

Ultimately, prep sets you up for success. If you’re not doing your preparation properly, you’re not going to get a good installation of a protective coating.

Application Errors

Even if the preparation is done well, using low quality materials for the final coating will lead to failure. The old adage, you get what you pay for applies here. If the product is cheap, it’s probably cheaply made.

Using the wrong type of coating will also lead to the decline of the roof’s coating.

Making sure to ask questions of your contractor (or potential contractor) about what type of material is being used will help you better understand if the coating used will indeed last a long time.

For example, in our colder Alberta climate, acrylic coatings don’t work as well as silicone coatings. Acrylic is more susceptible to pooling water and UV damage. Being water based, acrylic can harden and crack and become unstuck. Silicone, however, is a great product to use here in Alberta. It endures the cold well and withstands UV light and water.

A new to the market coating called Naturaseal is a product that Beyond is considering using on future projects. It’s made from recycled materials which means it’s environmentally friendly. It’s been quite successful in Ontario, so our team at Beyond is hopeful it will do well here in Alberta too. More on that in another blog one day.

The improper technique when applying the coating is another way the coating can fail. If a silicone coating is being applied over an acrylic coating, even a clean and dry acrylic coating, it’s bound to deteriorate over time.

Environmental Factors

Metal roof coatings do have limitations, but they’re mainly due to temperature and weather.

Working on a metal roof means working outside and sometimes Mother Nature likes to keep us on our toes. If it rains, the roof will need to be properly dried again before the coating can be applied. Moisture contamination will absolutely affect the coating's adhesion, so it bears repeating that the roof needs to be completely dry before installing a coating.

When it comes to outside temperature, if it’s above zero degrees Celsius, roof coatings can be installed at almost any time of year, although any type of coating generally needs warmer temperatures to cure properly.

Outside of these mistakes and errors (and our sometimes-unpredictable weather), installing metal roof coatings is really a simple, no-nonsense job. As long as the proper protocols for prep and application are done correctly, and the right product for the job is being used, a metal roof coating should not fail.

Our roofing team at Beyond is always happy to chat about your project, whether looking into coatings for the first time or wanting to reapply a new coating or discuss failed coatings. Give us a shout or shoot us an email and our team will walk you through what we offer.

back to stories